Automotive

In the quest for eco-friendly transportation, consumers often face a challenging decision: is it more environmentally responsible to continue driving a used gasoline-powered car or to invest in a new electric vehicle (EV)? While EVs are lauded for their zero tailpipe emissions, the production process, particularly battery manufacturing, carries a significant environmental footprint. Conversely, used cars have already incurred their manufacturing emissions, but their ongoing operation contributes to greenhouse gas emissions. This article explores the environmental impact of electric vehicles compared to used gasoline cars to help you make an informed choice.

1. Manufacturing Emissions: The Hidden Cost of New Cars

Producing a new vehicle, regardless of its power source, involves substantial energy consumption and resource extraction. EVs, in particular, require energy-intensive battery production, leading to higher initial manufacturing emissions compared to internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles. According to a study by the Zemo Partnership, a typical mid-sized gasoline car generates approximately 5.6 tons of CO? during production, whereas a comparable EV produces around 8.8 tons, with nearly half attributed to the battery. However, these upfront emissions are offset over time by the EV’s cleaner operation. In contrast, purchasing a used car avoids new manufacturing emissions but perpetuates the use of older, less efficient technology. 

2. Operational Emissions: Tailpipe vs. Power Plant

Once on the road, EVs produce zero tailpipe emissions, significantly reducing pollutants like nitrogen oxides and particulate matter. However, the environmental impact depends on the electricity source used for charging. In regions where the grid relies heavily on fossil fuels, the benefits are diminished but still favorable compared to gasoline vehicles. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency notes that, over their lifetime, EVs typically result in lower total greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline cars, even when accounting for electricity generation. Used gasoline cars, especially older models, often have lower fuel efficiency and higher emissions, contributing more significantly to air pollution and climate change. 

3. Longevity and Break-Even Point: When Do EVs Become Greener?

The environmental advantage of EVs becomes apparent over time as they offset their higher manufacturing emissions through cleaner operation. Studies indicate that, depending on driving habits and energy sources, EVs can surpass gasoline vehicles in environmental performance within 6 to 18 months of use. Therefore, the more you drive an EV, the greater its environmental benefits. Conversely, if a used gasoline car is nearing the end of its lifespan, continuing to drive it may result in lower overall emissions than producing a new EV. However, this balance shifts if the used car has many years of use remaining, during which it will continue to emit greenhouse gases. 

4. Resource Extraction and Recycling: The Battery Factor

EV batteries require materials like lithium, cobalt, and nickel, whose extraction can have significant environmental and social impacts, including habitat destruction and pollution. Efforts are underway to improve mining practices and develop recycling technologies to mitigate these effects. Recycling EV batteries can reduce the need for new raw materials and lower the environmental footprint of battery production. In contrast, gasoline vehicles rely on continuous oil extraction and refining, processes associated with substantial environmental degradation. Transitioning to EVs and improving battery recycling can thus offer long-term environmental benefits over the persistent impacts of fossil fuel use. 

5. Global Impact: Exporting Emissions

When used gasoline cars are sold or exported to developing countries, they often continue to operate for many years, contributing to global emissions and local air pollution. A report by Wired highlights that between 2015 and 2020, developing countries imported 23 million used cars, many lacking modern emission controls. This practice shifts the environmental burden from wealthier nations to those with fewer resources to manage pollution. In contrast, promoting the adoption of EVs globally can help reduce overall emissions and improve air quality worldwide. Therefore, the decision to replace a used gasoline car with an EV can have positive implications beyond individual carbon footprints. 

Weighing Your Options: Making the Eco-Friendly Choice

Deciding between keeping a used gasoline car and purchasing a new EV involves considering various factors, including the vehicle’s remaining lifespan, driving habits, and local energy sources. If your used car is relatively efficient and has many years of use left, continuing to drive it may be environmentally justifiable. However, if you’re facing frequent repairs or poor fuel economy, transitioning to an EV could offer greater environmental benefits over time. Additionally, exploring the option of buying a used EV can combine the advantages of avoiding new manufacturing emissions with the operational benefits of electric driving. Ultimately, the most sustainable choice depends on your specific circumstances and commitment to reducing your environmental impact.

What factors influence your decision between a used gasoline car and a new or used electric vehicle? Share your thoughts and experiences in the comments below.

Read More

4 Muscle Cars That Still Blow Modern EVs Off the Line

Why Some People Are Ditching EVs and Going Back to Gas

Drew Blankenship is a former Porsche technician who writes and develops content full-time. He lives in North Carolina, where he enjoys spending time with his wife and two children. While Drew no longer gets his hands dirty modifying Porsches, he still loves motorsport and avidly watches Formula 1.