The hidden cryptocurrency investing risk no-one is talking about

March 10, 2025

Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies have been back in the spotlight, after soaring on the back of Donald Trump’s election, then plummeting back down again before getting another boost when the president fleshed out some details about a proposed US crypto reserve.

The risk of dramatic ups and downs in the market are well known, and investors shouldn’t get into it without realising they could lose everything.

However, it’s not the only risk to be aware of – because even if you make money on crypto, you could be felled by tax.

Read more: How to save money when you’re single

If you earned the crypto through work, or made it by mining it, then you could be in the frame for income tax. But if you bought it, the tax to worry about is capital gains tax (CGT).

If you bust the limit when selling cryptocurrency, basic-rate taxpayers could pay 18% on gains, while higher and additional rate taxpayers could be saddled with a 24% levy.
If you bust the limit when selling cryptocurrency, basic-rate taxpayers could pay 18% on gains, while higher and additional rate taxpayers could be saddled with a 24% levy. · d3sign via Getty Images

You’ll need to work out what gain you’ve made. You can pool the cost of the coins you’re selling (assuming they are the same type of coins), considering what you paid for each of them, and then working out an average cost per coin.

Then you can work out the gain by subtracting that from the selling price. It means you need to be certain about what you paid for the coins and how much they have gained in value since then.

Read more: How to negotiate house prices

You then need to either pay the capital gains tax immediately, using the real time service, or complete a self-assessment tax return at the end of the tax year.

You might not have to pay tax on all of the gain. If some of the coins you’re disposing of have lost value, you can offset the loss against any gains, but you need to report the loss to HMRC in order to do so.

You can also often subtract the transaction fees – which can be substantial when you sell crypto.

All this means you need to keep good records – including the date of disposal, the pooled costs before and after you disposed of them, the number of tokens you have left, and the value of them. You also need to hang onto bank statements and wallet addresses, because HMRC might ask to see any of these things if they carry out a check on your accounts.

Don’t assume your wallet will be the only record you need, because this isn’t necessarily stored for long. The exchange may not even exist when HMRC comes calling.

You may have bought crypto for the excitement of riding the rollercoaster, so the fact it comes with a hefty burden of admin is unlikely to come as a pleasant surprise.
You may have bought crypto for the excitement of riding the rollercoaster, so the fact it comes with a hefty burden of admin is unlikely to come as a pleasant surprise. · Thomas Barwick via Getty Images

To some people this may sound like a real faff, and they may wonder whether they need to bother at all, so it’s worth knowing that HMRC works with the major exchanges and can access your customer information and transaction data.

The autumn budget last year also revealed HMRC would be keeping a closer eye on digital assets. Worldwide crypto activity from the start of 2026 will be reported automatically to the taxman – with the first reports hitting at the end of May 2027.

If you don’t disclose gains and pay the tax that’s due, the authorities can find you through the exchanges and charge tax – and possibly a penalty. Depending on how concerted your efforts to hide the gain, these fines can be really substantial.

It means that if you hold digital coins, and the tax threat has never occurred to you, you’re going to need to spend some serious time getting the paperwork in order.

You may have bought crypto for the excitement of riding the rollercoaster, so the fact it comes with a hefty burden of admin is unlikely to come as a pleasant surprise.

Read more:

Download the Yahoo Finance app, available for Apple and Android.

Terms and Privacy Policy

 

Search

RECENT PRESS RELEASES