Trump wants to ban Wall Street investments in single-family homes. Experts aren’t sure it

January 8, 2026

President Trump said he wants to ban institutional investors from buying up more single-family homes, a policy that has rare bipartisan support in Congress and broad popular appeal.

“People live in homes, not corporations,” Trump posted on Truth Social on Wednesday. The announcement sent shares of private equity giant Blackstone, which has amassed a broad rental home portfolio, and rental specialists like Invitation Homes and American Homes 4 Rent sharply lower.

The only problem? Experts don’t think it will make a major difference in the affordability crisis.

Policies that encourage building, particularly dense housing in sought-after neighborhoods, are more likely to help improve affordability than banning institutional landlords, said Daryl Fairweather, chief economist at Redfin.

Learn more: Housing market predictions: What buyers, renters, and homeowners can expect

“The reason housing has gotten so unaffordable is because there is a shortage of homes,” Fairweather said. “It’s the shortage of homes that makes investors want to buy the homes because they see that there’s scarcity.”

Giant landlords — typically defined as those who own over 1,000 homes — have been under fire since the aftermath of the financial crisis, when they began buying up homes at beaten-down prices, fixing them up, and renting them out. Critics say their actions push up rents and home prices by reducing the supply of homes that would otherwise go to owner-occupants and that many corporate landlords are quick to evict but slow to provide basic maintenance.

But for all their purchases — the largest companies own around 80,000 homes — institutions make up only a tiny fraction of the US housing market. They own around 3.4% of all rental homes, and landlords with 100 or more homes make less than 1% of all purchases, according to housing consultancy John Burns Research and Consulting.

“Institutional investors get so much buzz,” said Rick Palacios Jr., the company’s director of research. “It’s really easy to pick on. You’re hard-pressed to put a bull’s eye on this industry when you actually look at the hard statistics.”

The US rental market remains dominated by “mom-and-pop” investors who own fewer than 10 homes. They have continued to be active in the space, buying up around 14% of homes in the third quarter of 2025, according to data provider Cotality. The largest investors, meanwhile, made 2.5% of purchases in that period.

Even so, corporate landlords’ presence in the market is uneven: Larger investors have concentrated their investments in fast-growing southeastern metropolitan areas. One study by the Government Accountability Office found that large investors held 25% of the single-family market in Atlanta, 21% in Jacksonville, Fla., and 18% in Raleigh, N.C, as of 2022.

Wall Street’s preference for buying homes in fast-growing areas with healthy job markets makes it extra difficult to parse out how they influence rents, said Selma Hepp, chief economist at property data company Cotality.

“The research has been very inclusive,” Hepp said. “What happens first is you have a high-demand area where rents go up, and that’s when institutional investors come in or investors in general come in, not the other way around.”

Joshua Coven, an assistant professor of real estate at Baruch College’s Zicklin School of Business, has worked to quantify the impact of institutional investors in the market. In a paper last year, he found that large landlords decrease rents by contributing to the rental supply, and policies like banning larger landlords or forcing them to cap rent increases could hurt supply and push up rents.

However, he also found that by buying homes, large landlords decrease the supply of homes available for ownership, accounting for about 20% of price increases in the markets where they’re most active.

“This makes it harder for people to buy homes, because it does raise prices,” Coven said. “And it lowers the amount of homes available for an owner-occupant. At the same time, they’re then renting these homes out, which increases the rental supply.”

Read more: Is now a good time to buy a house?

Claire Boston is a Senior Reporter for Yahoo Finance covering housing, mortgages, and home insurance.

Sign up for the Mind Your Money newsletter

Click here for the latest personal finance news to help you with investing, paying off debt, buying a home, retirement, and more

Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance

Terms and Privacy Policy