What happens if Common Municipal Solid Waste Management Facilities (CMSWMFs) are exempted from mandatory environmental clearances?

Would that mean risking oversight precisely when India’s cities need it most?

As urban waste continues to grow in scale and complexity, can the country afford to implement weaker safeguards without endangering millions who live near landfills, industrial drains, and polluted air?

The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC)’s draft notifications on October 3, 2025, propose a key amendment to the EIA Notification, 2006, to exempt Common Municipal Solid Waste Management Facilities (CMSWMF) from the requirement of prior Environmental Clearance (EC).

This exemption could weaken accountability at a critical moment. India’s waste management sector is no longer a local sanitation concern but a national health and climate challenge.

Without rigorous environmental vetting, efforts to modernise urban waste systems may come at the expense of community wellbeing and long-term ecological security.

Urban India’s waste stream has expanded dramatically, from 33 million tonnes in 2000 to over 100 million tonnes, projected to reach 125 million tonnes by 2031.

Alongside, electronic waste, plastics, and hazardous debris are mounting, straining facilities already struggling under inconsistent supervision. The challenge is not one of policy absence but implementation fatigue and weak institutional capacity.

Policy frameworks like the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act (1974) and the Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act (1981) were designed to guard against such hazards, empowering state pollution control boards.

However, across states, systemic strain is evident. For example, despite a sharp increase in waste management budgets between 2018 and 2024, the Comptroller and Auditor General’s 2025 audit in Uttar Pradesh found idle plants, unutilised machinery, and open dumping without methane or leachate management.

The human cost of these governance deficits is seldom acknowledged. Jharkhand’s pollution control board reports technical staff vacancies exceeding 80%, while across nine states, average vacancies stand around 40%, meaning insufficient inspection, weak compliance, and mounting pollution risks for millions.

So why are environmental clearances so critical in this context? Often dismissed as red tape, they remain the backbone of environmental accountability. These clearances require assessments spanning air, water, soil, biodiversity, and human health checks that ordinary consent processes overlook.

They compel disclosure and public hearings, giving local communities a voice in projects likely to shape their environment. Diluting these safeguards means silencing those most vulnerable, informal workers, children, and families living near landfills who bear the brunt of mismanaged waste.

The consequences are visible in every major city. Poorly regulated landfills emit methane and volatile compounds, polluting air and groundwater. Repeated landfill fires in Delhi and Mumbai, and leachate pollution in Bengaluru.

Kolkata and Patna show how lapses in oversight morph into urban health emergencies. Environmental clearance, then, is not a procedural hurdle; it is a public health defence.

India’s task is not to discard oversight, but to reform it. Efficiency and innovation in waste management cannot substitute for rigorous environmental standards.

Strengthening state pollution control boards through staffing, training, and technology is essential. A tiered environmental clearance system, fast-tracking smaller projects while maintaining full reviews for large or sensitive ones, can combine efficiency with accountability.

Tools like IoT sensors, satellite monitoring, and public dashboards can make pollution control transparent and continuous. Crucially, citizen engagement must go beyond symbolic hearings to ongoing consultation and grievance redressal.

Rapid infrastructure growth need not come at the cost of environmental security. Exempting pollution-intensive facilities risks undermining years of progress. Instead, India should invest in modern, science-based regulatory systems that reinforce both economic growth and ecological stability.

Strengthened environmental clearances can turn waste management into a cornerstone of urban resilience, protecting health, climate, and the promise of sustainable city life for generations to come.

END OF ARTICLE